
Pay-If-Paid vs. Pay-When-Paid Clauses in California Subcontracts
Last updated: November 2026
In California, pay-if-paid clauses are unenforceable under Wm. R. Clarke Corp. v. Safeco Ins. Co. (1997), while pay-when-paid clauses are generally read as setting the timing of a subcontractor’s payment. The difference turns on whether the owner’s payment is a condition of the general contractor’s duty to pay, and on how long the clause makes the subcontractor wait.
If you sign or draft California subcontracts, whether as a subcontractor, general contractor or developer on projects in San Diego, Los Angeles or elsewhere in the state, this is the rule you work under. California’s answer comes from two court decisions and the lien statutes behind them.
What is the difference between pay-if-paid and pay-when-paid clauses?
A pay-if-paid clause makes the owner’s payment to the general contractor a condition precedent to the general contractor’s duty to pay the subcontractor. A pay-when-paid clause ties the timing of the subcontractor’s payment to the general contractor’s receipt of owner funds. The first decides whether the subcontractor gets paid at all. The second decides when.
A condition precedent is an event that has to happen before a contract duty exists. The California Supreme Court used that idea in Wm. R. Clarke Corp. v. Safeco Ins. Co. (1997) 15 Cal.4th 882, describing a pay-if-paid provision as one that “makes payment by the owner to the general contractor a condition precedent” to the contractor’s duty to pay.
As of November 2026, California case law treats the two clause types this way.
| Pay-if-paid | Pay-when-paid | |
|---|---|---|
| What the clause does | Makes owner payment a condition precedent to the general contractor’s duty to pay | Links the timing of payment to when the general contractor receives owner funds |
| If the owner never pays | The clause says the subcontractor is never paid | Under Clarke, the subcontractor is still owed payment within a reasonable time |
| Effect on lien and bond rights | Clarke: an indirect waiver of mechanics lien rights | Crosno: an open-ended wait that impairs bond rights violates Civil Code 8122 |
| How California treats it | Unenforceable (Clarke, 1997) | Generally a timing term; not enforceable when the wait is indefinite (Crosno, 2020) |
For a subcontractor, the label on the clause matters less than what it does. Read the words that tie your payment to the owner, then ask whether they condition payment or only time it.
Why are pay-if-paid clauses unenforceable in California?
Pay-if-paid clauses are unenforceable in California because the California Supreme Court held in Clarke, decided June 26, 1997, that they are “contrary to the public policy of this state.” The court found that conditioning a subcontractor’s right to be paid on the owner’s payment works as an indirect waiver of the subcontractor’s mechanics lien rights.
The court built that ruling on two sources. The first is Article XIV, section 3 of the California Constitution, which says “Mechanics, persons furnishing materials, artisans, and laborers of every class, shall have a lien upon the property.” The second was the anti-waiver statute then in force, former Civil Code section 3262, which made contract terms that waive or impair other people’s lien claims “null and void.”
A pay-if-paid clause is not a formal lien waiver. The court looked at its practical effect anyway. If the subcontractor’s right to payment disappears when the owner fails to pay, the lien that secures that payment loses its value.
Clarke also addressed the payment bond. The court held that a pay-if-paid clause did not shield the general contractor’s surety, stating that “the payment bond obligates Keller to pay the subcontractors’ valid mechanic’s lien claims.”
The same anti-waiver principle appears in California’s current mechanics lien law. Under Civil Code section 8122, an owner, direct contractor or subcontractor “may not, by contract or otherwise, waive, affect, or impair any other claimant’s rights” under that part of the code. Such a term is void unless the claimant signs and delivers a statutory waiver and release.
Clarke’s holding refers to “pay if paid provisions like the one at issue here,” so the exact wording of your clause still matters.
When can a pay-when-paid clause still be unenforceable?
A pay-when-paid clause can still be unenforceable in California when it makes a subcontractor wait an indefinite time for payment. In Crosno Construction, Inc. v. Travelers Casualty & Surety Co. of America (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 940, the Court of Appeal refused to enforce such a clause against a subcontractor’s payment bond claim.
Crosno involved two steel reservoir tanks for the North Edwards Water District, a public works project. The owner withheld payment during a dispute with the general contractor. The subcontractor, Crosno Construction, sued the surety on the general contractor’s payment bond for its unpaid balance.
The subcontract said the general contractor would pay within a “reasonable time” after receiving owner payment, but “in no event less than the time Contractor and Subcontractor require to pursue to conclusion their legal remedies.” The surety argued the bond claim was premature under that clause.
The court disagreed. It found the clause would force the subcontractor to wait an indefinite time while the general contractor and the owner fought. It also held that the clause violated Civil Code section 8122, because the statute’s “affect, or impair” wording reaches terms that change a claimant’s rights even without waiving them outright.
The court did not strike down pay-when-paid clauses as a group. According to a published summary of the opinion, the court “clearly stated that not all pay-when-paid provisions are unenforceable,” and it declined to rule on hypothetical clauses.
Crosno decided a bond claim. The same summary notes that whether the same reasoning reaches a subcontractor’s direct contract claim against the general contractor was left open.
How fast must a California contractor pay a subcontractor?
California Business and Professions Code section 7108.5 requires a prime contractor or subcontractor to pay a subcontractor “not later than seven days after receipt of each progress payment,” unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. The rule applies to private and public works of improvement, except projects governed by Public Contract Code section 10262.
Under section 7108.5, a contractor with a good faith dispute may withhold “no more than 150 percent of the disputed amount.” A violation is grounds for disciplinary action. It also carries a penalty to the subcontractor of 2 percent of the amount due per month, and the prevailing party in a collection action recovers attorney’s fees and costs.
Retention has its own clock. On private works, Civil Code section 8814 requires a direct contractor to pay each subcontractor its share “within 10 days after receiving all or part of a retention payment.” On public works, Public Contract Code section 7107 sets seven days after the original contractor receives retention. Our post on retainage in California construction contracts covers those retention rules.
What should you check in a subcontract payment clause before signing?
Before signing a California subcontract, check whether the payment clause conditions payment on the owner paying, how long it could make the subcontractor wait, and whether it touches lien, stop payment notice or bond rights. Those three points decide how much of the clause would hold up and how much risk sits with each party.
Words such as “condition precedent” are the clearest sign of a pay-if-paid clause, since Clarke used that phrase to define one. Under Clarke, that kind of clause will not do what it says.
How long the clause could make you wait is a separate question. A clause tied to a fixed period after owner payment reads differently from one tied to the end of the general contractor’s litigation with the owner. The Crosno clause tied payment to the time needed to “pursue to conclusion their legal remedies,” and the court called that an indefinite wait. The seven-day rule in section 7108.5 yields to a written agreement, so on timing the subcontract’s own payment terms often control.
Waiver language is the part to read word by word. Under Civil Code section 8122, a subcontract term that waives, affects or impairs a claimant’s lien, stop payment notice or bond rights is void unless the claimant signs a statutory waiver and release.
General contractors face the other side of the same rules. A clause written as pay-if-paid will not shift owner nonpayment risk the way it reads. Under Clarke, the subcontractor is still owed payment within a reasonable time, even when the owner is slow. The time to address that is during construction agreement drafting and negotiation.
What can a subcontractor do when the general contractor won’t pay?
A California subcontractor that has not been paid can pursue a mechanics lien, a stop payment notice, a payment bond claim or a contract claim, depending on the project and the facts. Clarke and Crosno both turned on these protections.
A mechanics lien is a claim against the property for the value of work or materials supplied. Our guide on what a mechanics lien is explains how it works.
A payment bond claim runs against the surety that backs the general contractor’s payment obligations. Clarke held the surety liable despite a pay-if-paid clause. Crosno allowed the bond claim to go forward despite a pay-when-paid clause with an open-ended wait.
Each remedy has its own notice and timing rules, so the order of steps matters. Counterclaims are common too. Stryker Slev Law Group’s page for contractors notes that “An owner or general contractor will sometimes raise defect allegations to avoid paying a contract balance.”
For a broader look at resolving these fights, see our post on how to navigate payment disputes in construction.
Frequently asked questions
Does a pay-if-paid clause stop a subcontractor from claiming against the payment bond?
No. In Wm. R. Clarke Corp. v. Safeco Ins. Co. (1997), the California Supreme Court held that a pay-if-paid clause did not protect the general contractor’s payment bond surety. The court stated that “the payment bond obligates Keller to pay the subcontractors’ valid mechanic’s lien claims.” The bond obligation is separate from the subcontract’s payment terms, so the clause did not defeat the subcontractor’s claim against the surety.
Can a subcontractor give up its lien rights in the subcontract itself?
Not through ordinary contract language. California Civil Code section 8122 says an owner, direct contractor or subcontractor “may not, by contract or otherwise, waive, affect, or impair any other claimant’s rights” under the mechanics lien law. A term that tries to do so is void unless the claimant signs and delivers a waiver and release under the statutory article. A general waiver clause buried in a subcontract does not meet that requirement.
Can a general contractor hold back payment over a disputed item?
Yes, within limits. Under California Business and Professions Code section 7108.5, a contractor with a good faith dispute may withhold no more than 150 percent of the disputed amount. Wrongful withholding carries a penalty of 2 percent of the amount due per month, payable to the subcontractor. The prevailing party in an action to collect the withheld funds also recovers attorney’s fees and costs.
Can the parties agree to pay a subcontractor later than seven days?
Yes. Business and Professions Code section 7108.5 sets the seven-day deadline after receipt of each progress payment “unless otherwise agreed in writing.” A written subcontract can set a different schedule. That is a separate question from a pay-if-paid condition, which Clarke held unenforceable, and from an open-ended wait, which Crosno rejected on a payment bond claim.
How we can help
Stryker Slev Law Group represents contractors, subcontractors, developers and owners in construction payment matters throughout San Diego, Los Angeles and Southern California, from our office in San Diego.
We review subcontracts and payment terms before you sign, including pay-if-paid and pay-when-paid language. When payment is withheld, we pursue payment through mechanics liens, stop payment notices, payment bond claims and contract claims where the facts support them. You work directly with partners Dennis Stryker and Monica Slev.
Stryker Slev Law Group, 1620 Fifth Avenue, Suite 770, San Diego, CA 92101. Call (866) 531-5705 or contact us to talk through your subcontract or unpaid balance.
This article is general information about California law as of November 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Talk to a lawyer about the facts of your project.
Latest Posts
Pay-If-Paid vs. Pay-When-Paid Clauses in California Subcontracts
California courts treat pay-if-paid and pay-when-paid clauses very differently. See what Clarke v. Safeco and Crosno v. Travelers mean for subcontractors...
Understanding Retainage in Los Angeles Construction Contracts
California now caps retention at 5 percent on private contracts signed on or after January 1, 2026. See how retainage works on Los Angeles projects, when it...
Negotiating Fair Contracts for LA Real Estate Projects
Real estate projects often succeed or fail long before construction begins. The contract signed at the beginning of a project can determine how the parties...

